My last Stupid Vehicles post from 2006 still garners a fair bit of traffic (and has resulted in a few nasty emails from dedicated Ford Escape owners), so I figured I’d follow up with my top-10 list of stupid vehicles for 2008 - complete with my sarcastic, acerbic commentary you know and love.
1. Cadillac. I don’t normally give the stupid award to an entire brand, but they deserve it. Let’s briefly look at the offerings:
- The EXT. A Chevy Avalanche starts at $34,335. The EXT starts at $58,465. It’s the same truck, but for an extra $24,130 you get the “bling” factor of America’s most repulsive, garish brand name on the radiator grille. And who the hell buys a Cadillac truck, anyways? Don’t want to rough it in the back 40 with cloth seats?
- The ESV. I think there’s a special spot in hell for Cadillac SUV owners, and those who pick the ESV over the equally-ugly-and-no-more-practical Escalade get priority on the bus ride to purgatory. What better to scream “I’m a rich bastard who enjoys conspicuous consumption” than this 7200 pound, 18′ 6.4″ long monstrosity.
- The Escalade. It was on my original stupid vehicle list, and maintains its title for all the same reasons. Rappers and wannabe gangstas take a lesson from the Liberace school of refined style in this particular offering.
- The SRX. This baffling vehicle suffers from the same identity crises as most other crossovers. Big and bulky on paved roads and about as off-road worthy as a pair of roller skates, the SRX is about as unremarkable as … well, pretty much everything else from Cadillac’s stables.
- The XLR. “I wanna be a Mercedes SL so badly”. Something tells me they aren’t feeling much fear in Stuttgart.
- The DTS. Your grandfather’s Cadillac. The same car you’ll see for sale on the side of the road in 6 years for less residual resale value than a rusted out Korean econobox.
- The CTS. Your mom’s Cadillac. Trying so hard to compete, and still looking like it was styled by Lego.
- The STS. This is the successor to the Seville - that magnificent Cadillac that creepy, self-assured guys drove who thought they were God’s gift to women. Still cheesy, still tacky and still delightfully laughable to the rest of the automotive world.
But enough of Cadillac; I’m sure the bit above will garner plenty of hate mail. Let’s get back to the list.
2. Mercedes Benz GL550. OK, so I admit to having an irrational love with most things Merc … but this one just baffles me. From the Escalade school of excess and grotesque proportions comes the GL550; another vehicle destined never to see anything more offroad than parking on the lawn. I can almost live with the ML320; it’s a piddly-lame little thing of an SUV (with remarkably un-Mercedes like ergonomics), but the GL confounds me.
3. Scion Xd. What - a Toyota economy car in the dumb vehicle list? Now, I give Toyota props for producing phenomenally reliable, efficient vehicles, and I’m sure the Xd is just as capable of a performer as the other X-series Scions. My beef here isn’t actually with the car; it’s the stupid high-school-kid advertising and hype around it. I ain’t buying a Scion because I want to be the pinnacle of automotive styling and performance; I’m buying it because it’s a cheap car - and no glittery paint job, no set of low-profile tires and no window tinting will make it anything but a cheap car with a bunch of tacked-on junk. So please - leave the gaudy accessories to Cadillac.
4. Volkswagen Rabbit. My regular readers will think I’ve lost my cork on this one. A Volkswagen on the dumb-vehicle list, from the original Volkswagen man himself? Let me explain. Many years ago, Volkswagen turned the world on its edge with a little car called the Rabbit (for the non-North Americans reading, it was originally the Golf). This was back in the 70’s, when Detroit reigned supreme with huge-ass cars, and gas was starting to go up in price. The Rabbit proved that little cars could be good cars, and Volkswagen has done a remarkable job of keeping the Rabbit / Golf equation in check. But the latest iteration leaves me feeling cold; the base Rabbit ships with a rather lackluster 5 cylinder engine that won’t win any races (a remarkably pedestrian 0-60 in 7.8 seconds) and won’t leave you bragging like you did with your old Golf Diesel (22/30 MPG). It’s a pretty car, yes, and it handles well, but it’s not as sharply delineated from the competition as it used to be. All in all, it’s an unremarkable car from a company that’s capable of a lot more.
5. Ford Flex. From the Scion Xb school of styling comes the Ford Flex. I’m not sure what Ford was trying to do with this, but it’s not cheap (starting at over $27,000), and it looks big. The advertising makes me cringe, though - here’s a bit about the chrome rims: “Nine spokes of polished aluminum can say a lot about a person. We’re thinking words like confidant. Good taste. Attention getter. (Feel free to jump in at any time and start free-associating.) Slick. Attitude. High roller. Anyways, they’ll definitely say a lot about you.” I don’t know about you, but I don’t know many high rollers pimping it in their Ford Flex. Looks like another mommy-taxi-cum-wanna-be-off-roader to me.
6. Buick Enclave. Taking shots at Buick is like teasing the retarded kid in class … it’s almost too easy. From Buick’s own literature: “… the visceral allure of an enticing machine.” I don’t know how enticing a pimped-up Saturn Outlook is, but I know that the Enclave seems about as visceral as Chinese calculus.
7. Pontiac is CAR. I’ve been kind of rough on GM in this list, and I’m not going to single out any one Pontiac - but I will single out their new slogan. “Pontiac is CAR”? I close my eyes and imagine hundreds of guys with gold chains and tight jeans waving clubs and tire irons in the air as they chant this visceral mantra. Now, I’m going to let the brain trust at GM in on a little secret: most of us know that Pontiac is CAR.
8. Dodge Hemi. Quick - without looking on Google or Wikipedia - what does hemispherical mean? If your mind is drawing a blank (and instead thinking of those cool Hemi badges on the back of some Dodge vehicles), you’re in good company - most people don’t know a darned thing about what a Hemi actually is. These days, bragging about a hemispherical head is a bit like bragging about having spark plugs, since most engines these days have hemispherical heads. So please, Dodge - lay off the Hemi stuff. It’s just not cool anymore.
9. Jaguar XJ. A few days ago, an old 1970’s Jaguar V12 sedan passed me, and it struck me how mundane Jaguars of late have become. Jaguar was the epitome of British class and style for so many years; now, I could easily mistake it for any other mid-sized luxury car out there. And what the hell is up with the fuel door, anyways? I thought Jaguars were supposed to have two fuel filler caps just in front of the trunk? It’s this sort of disrespect for heritage that irks me. Hopefully Tata Motors can un-screw-up Ford’s whitewash job on a once-grand marque.
10. Hummer. Once upon a time, a little company called Hummer produced an amazing off-road vehicle that was built the way off-road vehicles should be. It drove like a tank (thanks, in no small part, to its close association with the military), it was not comfortable, and it was virtually indestructible. A few years later, Hummer is turning out the H2 and the H3 - veritable junk for the prissy masses. Or - penis envy for those who don’t want Cadillac’s shiny opulence.
Enjoy!